Should I Keep Writing?

Writers are an insecure lot.

It's easy to understand why. You screw up at work and your boss jumps on your case, quick to tell you exactly what you need to do if you want to keep your job stuffing dough into that pizza press. You screw up your writing ? well, ten weeks later you receive a polite, generic rejection letter in the mail that basically says: Thanks, but no thanks. There is no boss to tell you how you screwed up or how to make it better. You're on your own, Mr. Wannabee A. Writer. Go lock yourself in your bathroom/office until you figure it out.

Unfortunately, this lack of feedback goes against our very nature as homo sapiens. If there's no stop sign at the intersection, we have to give serious consideration to whether we're willing to stop or not. That can be a real chore for those of us who are busy trying to dig a dime out between the seat cushions for that double-mocha cappuccino on the way to work. Put in a stop sign and it's a no-brainer. You stop. Then you start digging for the dime.

But for a writer, feedback comes in only one form ? if you sell the story, you did something right. If you didn't sell it, you did something wrong. There are those who will try to tell you this isn't true. That you can get good feedback from your spouse or your girlfriend or your buddies. But these are the same people who said you were feeding dough into the pizza press just fine. You can't trust the opinions, good intentions or not, of people who are only casual observers. So ? did your story sell or didn't it?

Well ? no. But why can't the editor take an extra minute and just tell me what was wrong? you wonder.

Yours is not the only manuscript the editor has to read. There are stacks of manuscripts all over the office, some higher than the desktop, with more arriving in the mail everyday. Editors don't have an extra minute. Not if they plan to scarf down a sandwich between noon and twelve-fifteen and still have time for a bathroom break. Your story has a page, two at the most, to capture the editor's interest. After that, well, there's always another story on the stack.

Another reason why the editor doesn't tell you what's wrong: your story's a nightmare. It would take more time to explain the problems than it took you to write the thing.

And the biggest reason of all: hell hath no fury like a writer scorned. Offer some helpful advice and the editor has undoubtedly learned that too often what he gets in return is an indignant letter full of obscenities.

Finally, writers need to understand that editors don't have all the answers. Yes, it's true, editors are people, too. They have their likes and their dislikes, their stern beliefs, their misconceptions. While one editor may abhor your story, another may find it brilliant.I mention all this in case you weren't already insecure enough.

And I mention it because there's another dead end request editors get thrown at them quite frequently. It goes like this:

Dear Mr. Editor: Enclosed please find my short story, titled "A Story By Any Other Name." I hope you like it. I think it's the best thing I've written. If you decide not to buy it, could you please tell me why. And could you also tell me if I should keep writing. I'd like to know if I have a future doing this.

If you have to ask, the answer is no, you don't have a future and you shouldn't keep writing.

Writing is not a pursuit for those who are weak of heart. Nor those who are thin-skinned. It is a pursuit for those who love doing it.

William F. Nolan used to say that if you want to be a writer then you sit your behind in the chair and write. Charles Grant said that he writes because he has to; he can't imagine not writing.

You want to be a writer? Don't ask editors or anyone else if you have what it takes. They don't know. They can't tell you if you'll make it or not. They might be able to tell you if you need to develop your skills more, but you already knew that. Writing is a profession you never stop perfecting. There's always more to learn.

You want to be a writer?

Persevere.

Go write ? and persevere.

David Silva
The Successful Writer
http://thesuccessfulwriter.com

WBFS

FCAT writing fiasco MiamiHerald.com But on Tuesday, Florida got a preview of the crisis to come when the state Board of Education held an emergency meeting by phone to lower the bar on the FCAT writing test after plunging results essentially flunked 73 percent of fourth graders on the ... Lyons: Scoring for FCAT writing test misses markSarasota Herald-Tribune Florida lowers passing grade for state writing examUSA TODAY Steven Kurlander: State prefers to ignore reality behind poor FCAT writing scoresSun-Sentinel St. Augustine Record -Dothan First -Fort Myers Beach Observer all 281 news articles »

Writing's on the wall for McNabb ESPN By Ashley Fox | ESPN.com There is one franchise that would seem to be a perfect fit for Donovan McNabb, a place where he knows the system, the personnel, the expectations and the playbook, and he wouldn't have to mentor anybody. and more »

Writers on a New England Stage welcomes America's laureate of real life, Anna ... Foster's Daily Democrat PORTSMOUTH — Writers on a New England Stage, the celebrated author series presented by The Music Hall and New Hampshire Public Radio, welcomes Anna Quindlen, on Wednesday, May 23. Ms. Quindlen, a #1 New York Times bestselling author, Pulitzer Prize ... and more »

Lisa Rinna on writing a book about sex CNN "The Big Fun Sexy Sex Book" is a fun and innovative guide to rejuvenating your sex life and libido, co-written with renowned sex therapist Ian Kerner (who writes about sex on CNN's medical news blog, The Chart). The vivacious 48-year-old actress is ... and more »

U.S. News & World Report (blog)

No Joke: George W. Bush Writing a Book on Economic Growth U.S. News & World Report (blog) To wit: Former President George W. Bush is writing a book on—wait for it—strategies for economic growth. The Center for American Progress's Pat Garofalo caught this little tidbit and nicely summarized why the idea of Bush writing a book on economic ... and more »

How to Write About Israel Right Side News Writing about Israel is a booming field. No news agency, be it ever so humble, can avoid embedding a few correspondents and a dog's tail of stringers into Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, to sit in cafes clicking away on their laptops, meeting up with leftist ... and more »

ABC News (blog)

Mexican Writer Carlos Fuentes Dies at 83 Wall Street Journal (blog) By Jose de Cordoba MEXICO CITY – Carlos Fuentes, Mexico's most famous writer, and a world-known public intellectual, died Tuesday, depriving the nation of its most internationally recognized voice. Mr. Fuentes, a novelist, poet, diplomat, critic, ... In Writing, Fuentes Shed Light On Poverty, InequalityNPR Carlos Fuentes, Mexican Novelist Who Inspired Latin American Writing, DiesABC News (blog) Mexican author Carlos Fuentes diesABC Online Los Angeles Times -Reuters -San Francisco Chronicle all 941 news articles »

'Suburgatory' Creator on Writing a Finale That Guaranteed a Series Renewal Hollywood Reporter "I really wanted to create a lot of little loose threads so that there was no way they couldn't pick us up,” Emily Kapnek says. Going into Wednesday's Suburgatory finale, series creator Emily Kapnek wanted to make it very hard for ABC to deny the show ... and more »

Bloomberg (blog)

Why Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg Returned to Writing Code Bloomberg (blog) Mark Zuckerberg has returned to writing code after a six-year hiatus from programming, a fact revealed in Bloomberg Businessweek's story today on how the Facebook founder hacked the world of Silicon Valley. Like many young entrepreneurs, Zuckerberg had ... and more »

Short story writer takes home Sophie Kerr Award The Star Democrat Manion, an English major from Clarksville, took the prize with her submission of four short stories she considers to be works in progress, and excerpts of her thesis on the role of letter writing in literature a study that drew from the novels of Jane ... and more »